CONSTRUCTION GUIDE · Renovations & repairs
How to compare building quotes without missing the expensive gaps
Published · Reviewed 17 September 2026

Two building quotes can describe the same extension or refurbishment and still price very different jobs. One may include drainage alterations, decorating and waste removal; another may allow only for the main structure. Comparing the final totals first can disguise the decisions that will determine the eventual cost.
Give every bidder the same information
Issue the same drawings, specification and scope to each contractor. Date the documents and record revisions so nobody is pricing an earlier layout. If one contractor identifies missing information, share the clarification with the others. That creates a fairer comparison and reduces the chance of a disagreement becoming a variation after work begins.
Use a simple comparison sheet organised around work packages: preparation, structure, envelope, services, finishes and external reinstatement. Record whether each item is included, excluded or allowed for provisionally. A blank cell deserves a question; it should not be treated as a free inclusion.
Understand allowances and exclusions
An allowance is useful when a selection is genuinely undecided, but it needs a clear basis. Ask what quantity, quality and installation work it covers. A bathroom allowance may mean sanitaryware only, or it may include taps, tiling, waterproofing, plumbing and fitting. Those are substantially different commitments.
Check how provisional sums will be valued once the scope becomes known, and whether attendance, overheads and profit are included. Confirm VAT treatment explicitly. Groundworks, utility alterations and repairs to hidden defects are common areas where an assumption can materially affect the final account. Record the assumption and the agreed process for resolving it.
Compare the proposed delivery, too
Ask who will supervise the job, how specialist trades will be coordinated and what access the programme assumes. An occupied home with restricted deliveries is different from an empty property with a clear compound. A quote that assumes unrestricted access needs adjusting if the family must keep using the kitchen or only part of a commercial building can close.
Review proposed start dates alongside lead times for windows, steelwork and client-selected finishes. A short programme is only useful when its dependencies are credible. Ask which decisions are required before mobilisation and which can follow later without disrupting the sequence.
Put the agreement in writing
The accepted scope, price basis, payment stages, change procedure and completion arrangements should form a coherent written agreement. Citizens Advice recommends checking insurance and obtaining a written contract before agreeing to home improvement work. Its guidance also explains the distinction between an estimate and a quotation.
Avoid choosing solely on the largest discount or the most detailed-looking document. Seek answers that let you understand what will be delivered, how uncertainty will be managed and what evidence will accompany completion. A useful final exercise is to ask each contractor to describe three things that could change the price. Differences in the answers often reveal unresolved scope.
For a refurbishment enquiry, send CJC your drawings, priorities and any known constraints through our renovations and repairs service. Clear information at enquiry stage helps turn a broad budget discussion into a comparable proposal.
Guidance reviewed on 17 September 2026. Requirements and suitable construction details depend on the property and project; follow the applicable regulations and your appointed specialists’ advice.
